The biggest difference between a sleeve window and a new window is whether the main frame is removed. A sleeve window keeps the original main frame fixed to the wall and fits a brand-new aluminium frame and sashes directly into it, with no frame removal or cement patching; a new window with full frame removal takes out the main frame, installs the new window and then patches the opening with cement. Each method has its pros and cons, and the choice depends on the condition of the old frame and the owner's needs.
Many owners planning to replace their windows ask: "Is a sleeve window or a new window better?" In fact, neither method is always better. Below we start with the works involved and compare the two item by item to help you choose a suitable replacement method.
Sleeve Window vs Full Frame Replacement: How Do the Works Differ?
Sleeve window (also called over-framing): the technician removes the old sashes, keeps the original main frame, fits a brand-new aluminium frame and sashes inside the old frame, and after fixing them seals the joints between the old and new frames and the wall. Because the frame is not removed and the plaster around the window does not need to be chiselled away, the works are simpler.
New window with full frame removal: the technician removes the whole old window, including the main frame fixed to the wall, clears the opening, installs a brand-new aluminium window, then patches with cement and applies silicone sealant for waterproofing. A brand-new aluminium window replacement is alteration works involving the wall structure and must be Class II Minor Works compliant.
Sleeve Window vs Full Frame Replacement: Differences at a Glance
| Item | Sleeve window | New window with full frame removal |
|---|---|---|
| Main frame | Original main frame kept | Old main frame removed |
| Cement patching | Not needed | Needed |
| Scaffolding | Usually not needed | Usually removable and installable from indoors, depending on location |
| Duration | Whole flat usually done in one to two days | Involves masonry work, takes longer |
| Opening size | Shrinks slightly on each side | Original opening size kept |
| Waterproofing | Seals the joints between the old and new frames | Can fully deal with leaks between the old frame and the wall |
| Declaration | The Buildings Department currently has no declaration requirement for sleeve windows | Must be Class II Minor Works compliant (MW03 / MW04) |
| Reference price | From $3,500 | From $200 / sq ft (plus frame removal, generally from $1,000–$2,000 per window) |
For detailed prices see our sleeve window vs full frame replacement price comparison; actual costs are based on an on-site measurement and quote.
Pros and Cons of a Sleeve Window
Pros:
Cons:
Pros and Cons of a New Window with Full Frame Removal
Pros:
Cons:
Are Sleeve Windows Illegal? Do They Need to Be Declared?
The Buildings Department currently has no declaration requirement for sleeve windows, and a sleeve window is not illegal in itself. If the works involve removing the old frame and patching with cement, they count as a brand-new aluminium window replacement and must be declared as Class II Minor Works. Private flats submit to the Buildings Department; public housing, HOS and Tenants Purchase Scheme units submit to the Independent Checking Unit (ICU).
Amgen is a registered minor works contractor (MWC 316/2021) and states the method on the quotation; for works that need to be declared, we can handle all the paperwork.
Real Case: Same Estate, Two Different Choices
Two owners living in the same private estate both wanted to replace their windows. The first owner's old frames were still sturdy; only the hinges had oxidised and the handles had come loose, and he wanted to change his sliding windows to casement windows. After inspection the technician recommended sleeve windows, and the whole flat was done in just over a day with no cement patching.
The second owner's window sill leaked in every heavy rainstorm. The technician found that the joint between the old frame and the wall was leaking and the old frame had warped. Because a sleeve window cannot deal with leaks at the wall joint, the technician recommended a new window with full frame removal, redoing the cement patching and silicone sealant waterproofing, with a Class II Minor Works declaration.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a sleeve window or a new window better?
It depends on the condition of the old frame. If the old frame is still sturdy and the window edge does not leak, a sleeve window saves time and money; if the old frame is loose or warped, or water is leaking between the old frame and the wall, a new window with full frame removal is more suitable. The technician will recommend a suitable method after an on-site inspection.
Will the window be smaller after a sleeve window?
Slightly. The new frame sits inside the old one, so each side shrinks a little and the usable opening is slightly reduced. If you want to keep the original opening size, choose a new window with full frame removal.
Does a sleeve window need scaffolding?
Usually not. Sleeve windows can mostly be installed from indoors; scaffolding is only considered for the occasional overhanging location or one where work cannot be done safely from indoors. See do aluminium window works need scaffolding.
Is there a warranty for sleeve windows?
Yes. Amgen provides a 3-year warranty on sleeve window works, and the joints between the old and new frames and the wall are sealed at the same time.
Conclusion: Check the Old Frame First, Then Choose Between a Sleeve Window and a New Window
Neither a sleeve window nor a full frame replacement is absolutely better; the key is the condition of the old frame and whether the window edge leaks. Amgen Aluminium Windows holds licence MWC 316/2021 and provides sleeve window and brand-new aluminium window replacement services. When measuring on site we check the old frame first, then recommend a suitable method and state it on the quotation.
For enquiries, send us photos of your windows on WhatsApp at 6586 3435 to arrange a technician's on-site assessment.
Want to know what a replacement costs?
Enter the number of windows and their sizes and it becomes a clear enquiry — a free on-site measurement can be arranged.
Start a replacement quote




