Sleeve Window or New Window? Differences, Pros and Cons of Sleeve Windows vs Full Frame Replacement
Window Replacement·8 min read·Content reviewed by licensed minor works contractor MWC 316/2021

Sleeve Window or New Window? Differences, Pros and Cons of Sleeve Windows vs Full Frame Replacement

A sleeve window keeps the original main frame and fits a brand-new aluminium frame and sashes into it, with no frame removal or cement patching; a new window with full frame removal takes out the main frame and then patches the opening with cement. This article compares the two on works, cost, duration, opening size, waterproofing and declaration, and lists the pros and cons of each to help you choose the right replacement method. Amgen MWC 316/2021.

The biggest difference between a sleeve window and a new window is whether the main frame is removed. A sleeve window keeps the original main frame fixed to the wall and fits a brand-new aluminium frame and sashes directly into it, with no frame removal or cement patching; a new window with full frame removal takes out the main frame, installs the new window and then patches the opening with cement. Each method has its pros and cons, and the choice depends on the condition of the old frame and the owner's needs.

Many owners planning to replace their windows ask: "Is a sleeve window or a new window better?" In fact, neither method is always better. Below we start with the works involved and compare the two item by item to help you choose a suitable replacement method.

Sleeve Window vs Full Frame Replacement: How Do the Works Differ?

Sleeve window (also called over-framing): the technician removes the old sashes, keeps the original main frame, fits a brand-new aluminium frame and sashes inside the old frame, and after fixing them seals the joints between the old and new frames and the wall. Because the frame is not removed and the plaster around the window does not need to be chiselled away, the works are simpler.

New window with full frame removal: the technician removes the whole old window, including the main frame fixed to the wall, clears the opening, installs a brand-new aluminium window, then patches with cement and applies silicone sealant for waterproofing. A brand-new aluminium window replacement is alteration works involving the wall structure and must be Class II Minor Works compliant.

Sleeve Window vs Full Frame Replacement: Differences at a Glance

ItemSleeve windowNew window with full frame removal
Main frameOriginal main frame keptOld main frame removed
Cement patchingNot neededNeeded
ScaffoldingUsually not neededUsually removable and installable from indoors, depending on location
DurationWhole flat usually done in one to two daysInvolves masonry work, takes longer
Opening sizeShrinks slightly on each sideOriginal opening size kept
WaterproofingSeals the joints between the old and new framesCan fully deal with leaks between the old frame and the wall
DeclarationThe Buildings Department currently has no declaration requirement for sleeve windowsMust be Class II Minor Works compliant (MW03 / MW04)
Reference priceFrom $3,500From $200 / sq ft (plus frame removal, generally from $1,000–$2,000 per window)

For detailed prices see our sleeve window vs full frame replacement price comparison; actual costs are based on an on-site measurement and quote.

Pros and Cons of a Sleeve Window

Pros:

No frame removal or cement patching, with less dust and noise, so works can be done in flats that are already lived in
Saves the cost of frame removal, plaster repair and, in most cases, scaffolding
Short duration: a whole flat is usually done in one to two days
The window style can be changed at the same time, e.g. from sliding windows to casement windows (outward-opening windows)

Cons:

The new frame sits inside the old one, so each side shrinks slightly and the usable opening becomes a little smaller
If water is already leaking between the old frame and the wall, a sleeve window cannot deal with that joint
If the old frame is loose, warped or badly oxidised, the problem is simply sealed inside, so a sleeve window is not suitable

Pros and Cons of a New Window with Full Frame Removal

Pros:

The old main frame is removed, so the original opening size is kept
Leaks between the old frame and the wall can be dealt with at the same time, redoing the waterproofing from the source
Suitable for flats where the old frame is loose or warped, or where old iron windows have oxidised

Cons:

Cement patching is needed, so there are more steps and more dust and noise
Masonry work is involved, so the duration is longer
Class II Minor Works must be declared: submit MW03 at least 7 days before work starts and MW04 within 14 days after completion (see the aluminium window minor works declaration procedure)

Are Sleeve Windows Illegal? Do They Need to Be Declared?

The Buildings Department currently has no declaration requirement for sleeve windows, and a sleeve window is not illegal in itself. If the works involve removing the old frame and patching with cement, they count as a brand-new aluminium window replacement and must be declared as Class II Minor Works. Private flats submit to the Buildings Department; public housing, HOS and Tenants Purchase Scheme units submit to the Independent Checking Unit (ICU).

Amgen is a registered minor works contractor (MWC 316/2021) and states the method on the quotation; for works that need to be declared, we can handle all the paperwork.

Real Case: Same Estate, Two Different Choices

Two owners living in the same private estate both wanted to replace their windows. The first owner's old frames were still sturdy; only the hinges had oxidised and the handles had come loose, and he wanted to change his sliding windows to casement windows. After inspection the technician recommended sleeve windows, and the whole flat was done in just over a day with no cement patching.

The second owner's window sill leaked in every heavy rainstorm. The technician found that the joint between the old frame and the wall was leaking and the old frame had warped. Because a sleeve window cannot deal with leaks at the wall joint, the technician recommended a new window with full frame removal, redoing the cement patching and silicone sealant waterproofing, with a Class II Minor Works declaration.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a sleeve window or a new window better?

It depends on the condition of the old frame. If the old frame is still sturdy and the window edge does not leak, a sleeve window saves time and money; if the old frame is loose or warped, or water is leaking between the old frame and the wall, a new window with full frame removal is more suitable. The technician will recommend a suitable method after an on-site inspection.

Will the window be smaller after a sleeve window?

Slightly. The new frame sits inside the old one, so each side shrinks a little and the usable opening is slightly reduced. If you want to keep the original opening size, choose a new window with full frame removal.

Does a sleeve window need scaffolding?

Usually not. Sleeve windows can mostly be installed from indoors; scaffolding is only considered for the occasional overhanging location or one where work cannot be done safely from indoors. See do aluminium window works need scaffolding.

Is there a warranty for sleeve windows?

Yes. Amgen provides a 3-year warranty on sleeve window works, and the joints between the old and new frames and the wall are sealed at the same time.

Conclusion: Check the Old Frame First, Then Choose Between a Sleeve Window and a New Window

Neither a sleeve window nor a full frame replacement is absolutely better; the key is the condition of the old frame and whether the window edge leaks. Amgen Aluminium Windows holds licence MWC 316/2021 and provides sleeve window and brand-new aluminium window replacement services. When measuring on site we check the old frame first, then recommend a suitable method and state it on the quotation.

For enquiries, send us photos of your windows on WhatsApp at 6586 3435 to arrange a technician's on-site assessment.

Amgen Aluminium Windows
Amgen Window Engineering Team
Amgen Aluminium Windows Engineering Ltd
Licensed Contractor MWC 316/2021 | 20+ Years Industry Experience

Want to know what a replacement costs?

Enter the number of windows and their sizes and it becomes a clear enquiry — a free on-site measurement can be arranged.

Start a replacement quote
★★★★★

“師傅準時到達,很快便開展工程 ,手勢十分純熟,工具也十分齊備, 拆窗的時候十分小心, 更有向用戶解釋舊有和新裝窗門的優劣 ,和提醒一些有關窗戶保養需要留意的事項! 助手十分配合師傅,令工程進行得十分順利, 工程完畢後也有清理公共走廊。 有關文件也很快送達屋宇署, 確認工程及檢驗順利完成。 整體十分滿意!”

Philip Ho
Philip Ho
Google Review
★★★★★

“因之前安裝鋁窗師父量度鋁窗尺寸欠準確,導致下雨天雨水從窗邊滲進屋內,對我們造成很大困擾。從網上找到安進鋁窗工程公司,很快與該公司鄧主管聯絡。鄧主管很快便到我單位視察漏水原因,鄧主管解說詳細,找出漏水原因與鋁窗的大小及防水工程出現缺失有關,並隨即提供最合適的鋁窗方案。 安裝新鋁窗前,安進鋁窗的師父表現專業,解釋詳細,每一工序的作用都向我解釋清楚,讓我放心。安裝鋁窗當天,師父施工態度認真嚴謹,拆除舊窗與安裝新窗的過程十分專業,防漏防水的密封膠打得非常平整到位,細節處理相當認真嚴謹。 新裝的鋁窗在下雨天不會漏水,安進鋁窗提供3年保養,讓我感到有信心。 這次的體驗非常滿意,絕對值得強烈推薦給有需要的朋友!”

FRANKIE CHAN
FRANKIE CHAN
Google Review
★★★★★

“十分滿意傑師傅和助手 Miss Yau 的服務和工作態度。”

Camilla ymchu
Camilla ymchu
Google Review
★★★★★

“本人是更換屋內的所有鋁窗膠邊及窗鉸及防水, 先有專人到本人樓宇視察及報價一切都細心專業,到約定時間師傅及助手到本人家中進行維修更換亦表現專業完成後亦有清理好現場, 十分推薦給要有責任及專業的團隊”

Lisa
Lisa
Google Review
★★★★★

“公司有良好溝通,師傅都好細心🙏🏻整新窗同套窗的手工很好👍🏻”

Wade Leung
Wade Leung
Google Review
★★★★★

“負責人鄧小姐解釋詳盡,好有耐耐性,喺風季雨季屋企大裝修發現有窗口滲水問題聯絡鄧小姐之後雖然係安排日子上面遇到天氣變化不定期因素,但係鄧小姐好積極配合,同埋回覆得真係好快服務好到位,亦都會好同你詳盡咁解釋各樣問題,做咗窗口嘅防水同埋膠邊窗鉸等等嘅更換工程防水膠邊感覺手工唔錯,不過最重要最重要我真係覺得客戶服務同埋回覆好快,當你發現有問題嘅時候基本上都會好快回復,真係好重要,如果有突發事情嘅話搵唔到負責人又俾咗咁多錢真係會好嬲,所以非常之滿意,推薦大家!如果有朋友需要我都會推薦依間公司完全感受到係態度好好,而且有服務!”

Translate to English
shukwan ngan
shukwan ngan
Google Review
★★★★★

“專業服務,態度好👍”

Translate to English
Yu Chan
Yu Chan
Google Review
★★★★★

“銷售人員鄧小姐很有耐心幫忙處理及解答我的問題,而且更主動幫我協調溝通,非常感謝。 師傅十分專業有禮,防水做得很好,完工後亦會幫我詳細拍照記錄。甚至樓上冷氣機有漏水情況,亦主動提出並提醒我去通知管理處。”

Translate to English
c chan
c chan
Google Review
★★★★★

“我在網上找到這間窗維修公司,起初都心大心細唔知好唔好,結果師傅非常專業,唔使一分鐘安全地啲把窗拆了下來,而且把窗弄得新嘅一樣,非常順滑,如果係這個師傅處理,這樣高質素,就算高嘅價錢,我也覺得值得付出!最後多謝鄧小姐細心檢查,今次我只做了一半的窗,下次仍會找這間公司幫手,值得推介!”

Translate to English
Margaret
Margaret
Google Review · 在地嚮導
★★★★★

“王師傅很專業的處理工程,並在一些安全關鍵地方提出專業建議。工作態度認真和專業,值得嘉許。”

Translate to English
Hungfai lee
Hungfai lee
Google Review
★★★★★

“師傅好準時,換窗鉸、手制好熟手和快手,效率高,換完會仔細測試,並重點解釋開窗關窗不順的原因,分享小貼士如何保養窗框的軌道,令窗鉸正常滑動,值得推薦!”

Translate to English
chi keung Mok
chi keung Mok
Google Review
★★★★★

“用心服務,態度良好,工作專業”

Translate to English
Henry Lee
Henry Lee
Google Review
★★★★★

“師傅準時到達,很快便開展工程 ,手勢十分純熟,工具也十分齊備, 拆窗的時候十分小心, 更有向用戶解釋舊有和新裝窗門的優劣 ,和提醒一些有關窗戶保養需要留意的事項! 助手十分配合師傅,令工程進行得十分順利, 工程完畢後也有清理公共走廊。 有關文件也很快送達屋宇署, 確認工程及檢驗順利完成。 整體十分滿意!”

Philip Ho
Philip Ho
Google Review
★★★★★

“因之前安裝鋁窗師父量度鋁窗尺寸欠準確,導致下雨天雨水從窗邊滲進屋內,對我們造成很大困擾。從網上找到安進鋁窗工程公司,很快與該公司鄧主管聯絡。鄧主管很快便到我單位視察漏水原因,鄧主管解說詳細,找出漏水原因與鋁窗的大小及防水工程出現缺失有關,並隨即提供最合適的鋁窗方案。 安裝新鋁窗前,安進鋁窗的師父表現專業,解釋詳細,每一工序的作用都向我解釋清楚,讓我放心。安裝鋁窗當天,師父施工態度認真嚴謹,拆除舊窗與安裝新窗的過程十分專業,防漏防水的密封膠打得非常平整到位,細節處理相當認真嚴謹。 新裝的鋁窗在下雨天不會漏水,安進鋁窗提供3年保養,讓我感到有信心。 這次的體驗非常滿意,絕對值得強烈推薦給有需要的朋友!”

FRANKIE CHAN
FRANKIE CHAN
Google Review
★★★★★

“十分滿意傑師傅和助手 Miss Yau 的服務和工作態度。”

Camilla ymchu
Camilla ymchu
Google Review
★★★★★

“本人是更換屋內的所有鋁窗膠邊及窗鉸及防水, 先有專人到本人樓宇視察及報價一切都細心專業,到約定時間師傅及助手到本人家中進行維修更換亦表現專業完成後亦有清理好現場, 十分推薦給要有責任及專業的團隊”

Lisa
Lisa
Google Review
★★★★★

“公司有良好溝通,師傅都好細心🙏🏻整新窗同套窗的手工很好👍🏻”

Wade Leung
Wade Leung
Google Review
★★★★★

“負責人鄧小姐解釋詳盡,好有耐耐性,喺風季雨季屋企大裝修發現有窗口滲水問題聯絡鄧小姐之後雖然係安排日子上面遇到天氣變化不定期因素,但係鄧小姐好積極配合,同埋回覆得真係好快服務好到位,亦都會好同你詳盡咁解釋各樣問題,做咗窗口嘅防水同埋膠邊窗鉸等等嘅更換工程防水膠邊感覺手工唔錯,不過最重要最重要我真係覺得客戶服務同埋回覆好快,當你發現有問題嘅時候基本上都會好快回復,真係好重要,如果有突發事情嘅話搵唔到負責人又俾咗咁多錢真係會好嬲,所以非常之滿意,推薦大家!如果有朋友需要我都會推薦依間公司完全感受到係態度好好,而且有服務!”

Translate to English
shukwan ngan
shukwan ngan
Google Review
★★★★★

“專業服務,態度好👍”

Translate to English
Yu Chan
Yu Chan
Google Review
★★★★★

“銷售人員鄧小姐很有耐心幫忙處理及解答我的問題,而且更主動幫我協調溝通,非常感謝。 師傅十分專業有禮,防水做得很好,完工後亦會幫我詳細拍照記錄。甚至樓上冷氣機有漏水情況,亦主動提出並提醒我去通知管理處。”

Translate to English
c chan
c chan
Google Review
★★★★★

“我在網上找到這間窗維修公司,起初都心大心細唔知好唔好,結果師傅非常專業,唔使一分鐘安全地啲把窗拆了下來,而且把窗弄得新嘅一樣,非常順滑,如果係這個師傅處理,這樣高質素,就算高嘅價錢,我也覺得值得付出!最後多謝鄧小姐細心檢查,今次我只做了一半的窗,下次仍會找這間公司幫手,值得推介!”

Translate to English
Margaret
Margaret
Google Review · 在地嚮導
★★★★★

“王師傅很專業的處理工程,並在一些安全關鍵地方提出專業建議。工作態度認真和專業,值得嘉許。”

Translate to English
Hungfai lee
Hungfai lee
Google Review
★★★★★

“師傅好準時,換窗鉸、手制好熟手和快手,效率高,換完會仔細測試,並重點解釋開窗關窗不順的原因,分享小貼士如何保養窗框的軌道,令窗鉸正常滑動,值得推薦!”

Translate to English
chi keung Mok
chi keung Mok
Google Review
★★★★★

“用心服務,態度良好,工作專業”

Translate to English
Henry Lee
Henry Lee
Google Review

Schedule Your Window Inspection Today

Licensed Contractor MWC 316/2021 | Professional & Reliable | All 18 HK Districts